In the golden age of social media, brands flocked to influencers – looking to collaborate with someone who has a perfectly curated feed, high follower count, with an ability to make anything look aspirational.
For years, influencer marketing has been the go-to digital strategy. However, the digital landscape is shifting once again, and one question continues to crop up… ‘Are influencers still influential?’
Influencer marketing absolutely changed the game. It gave brands a shortcut to drive awareness, but somewhere along the way, audiences began to tune out, trust was lost and engagements dropped. Consumers started asking, “Do they really use that product or is it just another paid post?”
Waning impact
Despite their reach, traditional influencers sometimes fail to deliver the impact that brands expect, and high follower numbers no longer guarantee strong engagement or conversion rates. In fact, many brands spend large portions of their marketing budget on influencer partnerships, only to find the return on investment disappointingly low.
As authenticity becomes the new buzz word, brands are waking up to a powerful truth – that real people can drive real influence. Your customers, brand fans and employees offer something that most influencers don’t: genuine connection and trust within their circles.
The power of real world communities
A friend sharing a product recommendation in a group chat can hold more weight than a celebrity plugging the same item on Instagram. A passionate employee posting about their company’s new product often resonates more than a ‘stranger’ with a blue checkmark. Why? Because it’s real!
We worked with our client Burts Snacks on a ‘Everyman Influencer’ campaign, which saw us engaging with real people who have small followings on social media, but the followings are made up of friends, family and people they know in real life. Over four months, we outreached to over 60 people via Instagram DM, resulting in less polished posts but authentic product endorsements and UGC we could utilise on Burts’ own channels. We were able to build a community of ‘brand fans’ who we now work with on an ongoing basis, sending them the latest NPD to exclusively try, allowing us to nurture these long-standing relationships and leave a positive brand impact on them.

So, should brands ditch influencers altogether? Not necessarily. But it’s time to re-evaluate their role. Big name influencers may still have a place in the mix, but big isn’t always beautiful. Instead, consider a shift towards community-led marketing where everyday advocates create content, spread messages, and share authentic love for your brand.
If you’re a brand looking to make an impact in 2025 and beyond, start treating your customers like your influencers. Build PR campaigns that encourage real voices to share real stories. For more information on how Storm can help with food and drink PR campaigns, contact us on hello@stormcom.co.uk.
